What is the GOTO statement and why is it controversial?
The GOTO
statement in C language is a historical curiosity, often viewed with skepticism by experienced programmers. It is an instruction that allows you to jump to any part of the code, which might sound like a practical solution, but in reality can lead to bad practices. Dennis Ritchie, one of the creators of the C language, warned that this instruction was "highly abusable". Its excessive use generates code that is more difficult to maintain and understand, as it can break the clear sequential logic of a well-structured program.
A better practice is to use control structures such as if
loops, while
loops, or state machines to direct the flow of code. These practices not only improve code comprehension, but also enhance maintainability and debugging.
When to use GOTO in C?
Although the GOTO
statement is not recommended in most cases, there is one specific scenario where its use might be considered: when you need to exit a nested multilevel structure to a specific place, such as an error handling routine.
Example code for error handling
Imagine you have a robotics program with several sensors. If one of those sensors detects a critical error, you might want to reset your program or direct the flow to a routine that handles the error. This is where the use of GOTO
can be considered for fast and safe error handling. A code example would be:
#include <stdio.h>
int main() {
if () { goto error_handler; }
error_handler: printf("Error handler enabled.\n"); return 0;}
Use case in robotic systems or controllers.
Robots, having sensors as their "eyes", need to react immediately to failures in those sensors. If something goes wrong, you might want to use GOTO
to send the flow to the error handler to recalibrate sensors or shut down the system safely.
Similarly, in a hardware controller, such as a keyboard, a GOTO
could lead to the execution of a fault handling block as soon as a malfunction is detected.
Final considerations on GOTO
Although GOTO
has its uses in cases of specific emergencies where an immediate and direct output is required, it is crucial to understand that its implementation must be careful and restricted. Keeping its uses to exceptional situations will help ensure that programs are as clear and efficient as possible.
Programming in C, as in many other languages, benefits greatly from a structured and logical approach. The GOTO
statement, while potentially useful, should be viewed more as a last resort than as a regular solution. As a learning strategy, it is important to become familiar with this statement, but it is always best to explore other alternatives first. Keep learning and refining your programming technique to build clean and efficient code!
Want to see more contributions, questions and answers from the community?