Recursos
Resumen
Take a model where every finite rational test passes for f but δ = f(η(a)) is not zero, and explain why that can't happen: a height bound linear in B runs into canonical-height growth that is quadratic in B, so every root index has to be an ordinary integer.
The reduction you are completing
- [0:07] DPRM shows that integer solvability is undecidable. Over ℚ, searching finds a zero when there is one but can never prove there isn't. The paper never builds an existential definition of ℤ in ℚ.
- [0:33] For each f, the paper generates finite tests, each one answerable by finitely many ℚ-queries, such that f has an integer zero ⟺ every test succeeds. Given a ℚ-oracle, two parallel searches (one for an integer zero, one for a failing test) would decide H10(ℤ). What remains is the hard direction.
- [1:10] The encoding uses E: y² = x³ − d²x over F = ℚ(√2), with d = 75 − 53√2. E(F) has rank one, so mE(F) = ℤP. The tests give T_a = η(a)P, and η is additive and injective, not a ring map.
The squeeze, step by step
- [1:50] Compactness gives a ring R with a root a and indices in *ℤ, which may be nonstandard. If δ = 0 you are done. Otherwise |δ| ≤ C_f B^D, where B is the largest index.
- [2:34] The five-point estimate: h(s) ≤ H·M(s)^c, where M(s) is the squarefree product of the primes of odd contact with five fixed points of P¹.
- [3:04] Each contact prime divides δ to order at least K, so M^K | δ. Taking K ≥ cD gives M^c ≪ B, and so h(A) ≪ B for every A ∈ R.
- [3:35] On the curve, h(x(nP)) = 2ĥ(P)n² + O(1). The index that reaches B therefore satisfies 2ĥ(P)B² ≤ CB + C′.
- [4:01] Think-first: a parabola that has to stay under a line can only do so on a finite stretch, so B is bounded by an ordinary constant.
- [4:23] Every element of *ℤ in an ordinary finite interval is ordinary. Additivity and injectivity give a_j = n_j, so f(n) = 0, which contradicts δ ≠ 0. Hence there is no algorithm for H10(ℚ).
When you read a nonstandard argument, look for the same squeeze [4:56]: a linear bound against quadratic growth leaves a nonstandard index nowhere to hide. Next stop: Section 4. Why can only odd contact ramify the cover?